21 Food Kits You Can Order On Goldbelly That People Swear By (2024)

Each order comes with 2 pounds of pulled pork, two slabs of ribs, and 19-ounce bottle of Pappy's famous sweet barbecue sauce.

Promising review: "Arrived well-packaged, totally frozen with perfect cooking instructions— and the ribs were delicious!" —Betsy G.

Price: $129

Promising review: "My sister and I grew up eating Walter's hot dogs. She has been living in Florida for a while now and misses Walter's. Every time I have lunch there I send her a picture of my meal, but I decided to surprise her with a birthday care package of Walter's dogs. When she received the package I could hear her scream with joy." —Gretchen G.

Price: $69

Each box contains enough ingredients to make four lobster rolls and includes 12- ounces of lobster meat, 6 ounces of butter vinaigrette, four steam buns, and chives.

Promising review: "My parents raved about how delicious these lobster rolls were. They’ve been to Eventide in Portland so they know how these lobster rolls taste when they're fresh. They really liked how everything came together including the rolls, the butter, and the instructions." —Robert M.

Price: $99

Each pizza is seven by nine inches and you can select your favorite three pies.

Promising review: "The pizzas that I ordered arrived in perfect condition, still frozen and looking fabulous! I'll be giving this to my parents as a Christmas gift and I know they will be very happy." —Julie L

Price: $89

Each order contains two large White House Special sandwiches, sliced into halves, which feeds four to six people. The sandwiches arrive totally assembled besides for hot chopped peppers and oil on the side.

Promising review: "Everything was exactly the way I hoped it would be. The food was wonderful and totally fresh and arrived on time and it was packaged very carefully." —Michael P

Price: $99

In addition to the bagels, lox, babka, and schmear, which feeds six people, each box contains a Russ & Daughters mug, ground coffee beans, and a tote bag.

Promising review: "The shipping and packing was excellent! And the bagels, lox, and cream cheese was all FANTASTIC! The best." — Kate C.

Price: $169

Each order feeds two-four people and includes a pound of pastrami, a half-pint of coleslaw and Russian dressing, four slices of Swiss cheese, four slices of Jewish rye bread, and 2 pickles.

Promising review: "Our order arrived right on schedule. We are now stuffed with the best pastrami and rye bread we have ever eaten!" —Judy A.

Price: $109

Each of the 9-inch pies serve approximately eight to ten people.

Promising review: "Grand Traverse Pie Company pies are fantastic. These tasted great and were just the size we expected. They were packaged beautifully to prevent them from breaking during the shipping process." —Patrica S

Price: $99 (available in 12 flavors)

Promising review: "Our shipment arrived in great condition with the ice cream absolutely frozen solid. We enjoyed all the flavors. It's some of the best Ice cream ever." —Gregg B.

Price: $79.95 (available in 22 flavors)

Each order includes a three-pound half brisket, two pounds of burnt ends, one rack of pork spare ribs, a 16-ounce bottle of barbecue sauce, and the option to add on a side like mac 'n' cheese, baked beans, or smoked chicken wings.

Promising review: ""The barbecue from Mighty Quinn's was the best burnt ends and baked beans that we have ever tasted! People were actually fighting over the leftovers, not that we had much left." —Brenda C.

Price: $169

Each order contains four 10-inch subs that serve four to six people, and you can choose to have your cheesesteaks with or without onions.

Promising review: "The package was delivered on the date it was supposed to arrive, the food was fresh and delicious, and we had authentic Philly Cheesesteak sandwiches for lunch in Eugene, Oregon." —Laura S.

Price: $99

Every order contains 16 6-ounce patties.

Promising review: "Our shipment came fresh and was packaged great! There's nothing like a Pat LaFrieda burger!" —Jean J.

Price: $109

You get two 10-inch muffuletta sandwiches, which should serve six to eight people. Each is filled with salami, ham, Emmental Swiss, Provolone, mortadella, and a briny olive and vegetable salad.

Promising review: This was our first time ordering. We had the Muffalleta and it was delicious. It was very cool to order something you could usually only find in New Orleans." —Adriana S.

Price: $109

Each of the six cups contains 16 oz. of banana pudding and serves 10 to 12 people.

Promising review: "The Banana Pudding was just as amazing as if we had purchased it directly at Magnolia Bakery. It was fresh, delicious, and wonderfully decadent. I appreciate that it arrived right on time for our Thanksgiving celebration." —Kelley S.

Price: $65

You choose your four pizzas from classic cheese, sausage, pepperoni, veggie, and crustless. Each nine-inch pizza serves about two people.

Promising review: "I ordered Lou Malnati's all the way to Hawaii and the pizza was perfectly frozen. I cooked it two days later and it was delicious." —Joe L.

Price: $95.99

Promising review: "This food was delicious! I already sent a package to my cousin. The lobster was a huge morale booster to enjoy while we are hunkered down at home. It was the taste and memory of our vacation, delivered to our door!" — Caren F

Price: $139

Each of the six crab cakes weighs about 4 ounces.

Promising review: "Really, really good crab cakes. As per the description, they were all crab and no filling. Truly delicious, and arrived in excellent condition." —Philip G.

Price: $82

Each sandwich kit comes with soft Italian bread, coleslaw, french fries, hot sauce, and your choice of deli meat: pastrami, capicola, corned beef, and genoa salami. You'll receive the ingredients to make four sandwiches.

Promising review: "I got this as a birthday gift for my husband and he absolutely loved it! He said the sandwich tasted as fresh as if he were eating it at the restaurant! The food was packaged very nicely and the step-by-step instructions were perfect!" —Tiffany N

Price: $89

This meal kit serves eight, and you can choose between sliced brisket, pulled pork, or pulled chicken. Each package includes two pounds of meat, eight slices of smoked provolone cheese, kaiser buns, and 16 onion rings, plus a bottle of their signature BBQ suace.

Promising review: "My package was delivered on time, but more importantly, the food was perfect. I spent a year and a half living in Kansas City and haven’t been there in a few years, but I loved the food. Goldbelly's service was a blessing and the food was extremely good. Thanks for bringing the great taste of KC to Michigan." —James S.

Price: $94.99

Promising review: "The knishes always arrive fresh. When you heat them up in the oven, they taste as if you just picked them up at Yonah's." —Alexandra P.

Price: $109 (available in 14 flavors)